Best fit for hot-weather makeup: Choose Kiero Prime Sun Gel for a light, fast-absorbing, non-sticky daily gel; choose SKIN1004 for a serum-like finish or Beauty of Joseon Aqua-Fresh for a watery, dewy feel.

  • For sweating outdoors, first choose a U.S. sunscreen labeled water resistant for 40 or 80 minutes.
  • Kiero’s SPF 40+/PA++++ gel is the clearest match for a lightweight daily layer under makeup.
  • To assess pilling, test the full sunscreen-and-foundation combination with your usual skincare and application method.

For summer makeup, Kiero Prime Sun Gel SPF 40+ is the strongest fit here if you want a light, fast-absorbing gel with a non-sticky feel. SKIN1004 Hyalu-Cica Water-Fit Sun Serum suits a serum-like finish, while Beauty of Joseon Relief Sun Aqua-Fresh suits a watery, fresh finish. For walks or exercise with heavy sweating, choose broad-spectrum SPF 30+ and a water-resistant sunscreen, as the American Academy of Dermatology recommends; the FDA requires its label to state a tested 40- or 80-minute interval.

I compare the makers’ texture and use claims, foundation-wear evidence, and the water-resistance information available for each formula.

Check the water-resistance label before the texture

In the United States, a sunscreen may use a “water resistant” claim only after the required testing. The FDA’s sunscreen-labeling guidance says a water-resistance claim identifies protection for 40 or 80 minutes while swimming or sweating. The labeling rule in 21 CFR § 201.327 ties those labels to test results and gives separate instructions for products that pass or do not pass the test.

For outdoor exercise, choose a product whose U.S. label states a 40- or 80-minute water-resistance duration, then reapply after the labeled interval and at least every two hours. The FDA says labels for sunscreens that are not water resistant must direct users to choose a water-resistant sunscreen if swimming or sweating.

A high SPF, a PA++++ rating, a watery texture, and a water-resistance duration answer different questions. SPF and PA ratings describe labeled UV protection; the water-resistance statement addresses how long the tested product maintains its protection during water exposure. The FDA also explains that sunscreens cannot be labeled “waterproof” or “sweatproof,” because they eventually wash off.

SunscreenBest fit by documented feelEvidence for foundation wearOutdoor sweat decision
Kiero Prime Sun Gel SPF 40+Lightweight, fast-absorbing, non-sticky daily gelKiero recommends use under makeupDaily SPF 40+/PA++++; choose by the U.S. water-resistance duration for heavy sweating
SKIN1004 Hyalu-Cica Water-Fit Sun SerumLightweight, serum-like, dewy finishMaker’s texture description, including a non-sticky finish and no white castSKIN1004 says Water-Fit Sun Serum has not undergone water-resistance testing
Beauty of Joseon Relief Sun Aqua-FreshWatery, quick-absorbing, fresh finishMaker-reported panelists describe a weightless, skin-like finishUse the U.S. water-resistance duration to decide fit for heavy sweating

1. Kiero Prime Sun Gel: best for a light daily gel

Choose Kiero if a quick-absorbing gel with a comfortable, non-sticky finish is your priority for daily wear under makeup. Its official product page describes Prime Sun Gel as a lightweight gel, recommends applying it as the last morning skincare step or before makeup, and says to reapply through the day as needed. The product is 50 ml and is listed with SPF 40+/PA++++, chamomile, azulene, and panthenol.

Kiero also describes Prime Sun Gel as moisturizing, soothing for sensitive skin, and antioxidant-protective, with a non-sticky finish.

The ingredient list includes fragrance. That makes this a less direct fit for someone specifically seeking a fragrance-free sunscreen.

2. SKIN1004 Hyalu-Cica Water-Fit Sun Serum: best for a serum-like finish

Choose the SKIN1004 option if you prefer a thin, serum-like texture and a dewy finish. The maker’s product page describes the Korean-market Hyalu-Cica Water-Fit Sun Serum as SPF50+ PA++++, lightweight, non-sticky, quick-absorbing, and without a white cast. This is a texture-led alternative to Kiero’s gel, with a glowy finish instead of the more general “non-sticky” feel emphasized on Kiero’s page.

In its guide to the formula, SKIN1004 distinguishes the Korean-market Hyalu-Cica Water-Fit Sun Serum SPF50+ PA++++ from a separate U.S. over-the-counter Sun Serum UV, labeled SPF50 and reformulated with panthenol and rice, oat, and soybean extracts. SKIN1004 says Water-Fit Sun Serum has not undergone water-resistance testing. For heavy sweating, choose a U.S. sunscreen whose package states its tested water-resistance duration.

3. Beauty of Joseon Relief Sun Aqua-Fresh: best for a watery, fresh feel

Choose Relief Sun Aqua-Fresh if you want a watery lotion texture, quick absorption, and a fresh finish. Beauty of Joseon’s official Aqua-Fresh page describes lightweight, non-greasy protection with rice seed water and panthenol, a quick-absorbing finish, and a fresh, dewy complexion. The brand presents it as a lighter, more hydrating alternative and says it suits all skin types, especially people seeking a lighter formula.

The maker’s product guide to Relief Sun and Aqua-Fresh identifies Aqua-Fresh as a chemical sunscreen with SPF 50+ PA++++. It also reports test-panel impressions of a watery, lightweight texture and a skin-like finish, with panelists who had oily skin preferring its weightless, hydrating feel.

Aqua-Fresh is the clearest fit in this shortlist for oily or combination skin because Beauty of Joseon lists those skin types for its watery, weightless formula.

What counts as evidence that a sunscreen pills under foundation?

A texture description, a brand’s “makeup-friendly” claim, and a test that applies foundation over a named sunscreen are different levels of evidence. Kiero’s cited page recommends its gel under makeup. SKIN1004’s product and hydration guides describe texture and moisture. Beauty of Joseon’s panel comments describe how Aqua-Fresh felt and looked. Each helps predict whether a formula might suit your preferences, while a direct sunscreen-and-foundation test answers the pilling question more closely.

A peer-reviewed study of skincare pilling evaluated layering in 528 Chinese women. Researchers used reference-coded sunscreen and foundation, applied them to facial sites, and rated visible pilling. They recorded pilling in 61 of 5,280 applications when foundation was placed over sunscreen, or 1.16%, in that study’s specific layering step.

Researchers recorded 61 pilling events in 5,280 applications when foundation was layered over the tested sunscreen, or 1.16% for that study’s coded product pair. The authors linked pilling patterns with skin characteristics and application methods. Your moisturizer, sunscreen, foundation, and application motion all shape the layers you test together. A light, fast-absorbing texture is a useful first screen; test it with the foundation you actually wear.

If you will sweat outdoors as well as wear makeup

For a day with both makeup and outdoor sweating, choose a water-resistant duration suited to the activity first, then compare makeup finish. The federal labeling rule also directs users to reapply immediately after towel drying.

If a water-resistant formula pills under your usual foundation, try it with fewer skincare layers and a pressing motion before changing products. If a lighter formula such as Kiero or one of the two alternatives gives you a better finish, reserve it for ordinary daily wear and use a clearly water-resistant product for the outdoor session.

A repeatable test with your own makeup

  1. Keep your normal skincare routine steady. Use the same moisturizer or serum each time, with fewer layers if they usually leave a tacky surface. The pilling study found different results with different base formulas, so changing the base can change the outcome.
  2. Apply the full sunscreen amount directed on its package. The independent study used a fixed dose across facial test areas, and the American Academy of Dermatology advises applying an adequate amount to exposed skin.
  3. Let sunscreen settle, then press foundation on, as SKIN1004 recommends. SKIN1004’s pilling guide identifies repeated rubbing as a trigger, making light pressing a useful, consistent method to test.
  4. Compare one change at a time. Try Kiero, the SKIN1004 formula that matches your carton, and Aqua-Fresh on separate days. Record whether you see flakes, patches, or separation, along with the number of skincare layers and the weather.
  5. Choose a water-resistant sunscreen for swimming or heavy sweating. Record its labeled reapplication timing separately from flakes or foundation separation.

For daily makeup, Kiero is the clearest pick for a light, quick-absorbing gel with a non-sticky feel. SKIN1004 and Beauty of Joseon offer two distinct lightweight alternatives, a serum-like dewy finish and a watery fresh finish. For long, sweaty outdoor wear, choose by the water-resistance duration on the U.S. label first, then use the routine test to find the foundation pairing that stays smooth.